Worked example Annual receipts Manual review required
Victoria
A 12 months personal pledge swap with annual receipts evidence and moderate baseline confidence.
Global poverty <-> Animal welfare
Offered action Donate 1% of my income to an evidence-backed poverty charity for 12 months.
Requested action Adopt a vegetarian diet for 12 months. Personal pledge swap 12 months Annual receipts Participant-stated importance 7/10 Counterparty minimum acceptable importance 8/10 Confidence: Medium
Not a platform moral ranking. This score reflects the participant's stated view, not Moral Trade's assessment of moral value.
Action evidence Receipts, donation records, and an annual review checkpoint.
Baseline confidence Moderate
Externality review Review whether the trade creates third-party harms, bad incentives, or objections from moral views not present in the match.
Factor codes human_review_required evidence_rule_named baseline_credibility externality_review_required no_global_moral_ranking
Next step: Attach or inspect one scoped artifact for each factual action claim before relying on the record.
Why this status: human review: a proof method is named, but the artifact still needs reviewer inspection before reliance.
Worked example; manual review required before reliance
Worked example Annual receipts Manual review required
Paul
A 12 months personal pledge swap with annual receipts evidence and moderate baseline confidence.
Animal welfare <-> Global poverty
Offered action Go vegetarian for 12 months, with a yearly check-in and visible meal log.
Requested action Donate 1% of income to an effective poverty fund for the same period. Personal pledge swap 12 months Annual receipts Participant-stated importance 8/10 Counterparty minimum acceptable importance 7/10 Confidence: Medium
Not a platform moral ranking. This score reflects the participant's stated view, not Moral Trade's assessment of moral value.
Action evidence Receipts, donation records, and an annual review checkpoint.
Baseline confidence Moderate
Externality review Review whether the trade creates third-party harms, bad incentives, or objections from moral views not present in the match.
Factor codes human_review_required evidence_rule_named baseline_credibility externality_review_required no_global_moral_ranking
Next step: Attach or inspect one scoped artifact for each factual action claim before relying on the record.
Why this status: human review: a proof method is named, but the artifact still needs reviewer inspection before reliance.
Worked example; manual review required before reliance